Key Notes
- A California judge denied the three memory manufacturers’ motion to dismiss.
- Buyers allege a 697% rise in conventional DRAM prices over 18 months.
- The ruling allows the case to proceed and does not establish liability.
Samsung Electronics (KRX: 005930), Micron Technology (NASDAQ: MU) and SK hynix (KRX: 000660) have lost an attempt to dismiss a proposed class action accusing them of restricting supplies of ordinary computer memory to drive up prices.
US District Judge Noël Wise ruled on November 14 that buyers had plausibly alleged an unlawful agreement. Her order allows the case to continue; it does not establish that the manufacturers colluded or award damages.
The 17 consumers and small businesses behind the suit allege that conventional DRAM prices rose 697% over 18 months as the three companies cut supply and redirected manufacturing capacity toward memory for AI systems.
The Fight Over AI Memory
DRAM supplies the temporary working memory used in computers, phones and servers. High-bandwidth memory, or HBM, is a specialized form used alongside AI accelerators.
The buyers contend that the manufacturers coordinated production cuts, a shift toward HBM and the withdrawal of older DDR4 products. They also point to decisions against expanding conventional memory output despite soaring prices. The complaint alleges that older DDR4 eventually cost more per gigabyte than faster DDR5.
The companies argue that their choices reflected independent commercial judgment in response to the same market pressures. Similar decisions by a handful of competitors, they contend, do not establish an agreement to restrict supply.
The dispute arrives alongside an earnings boom. Samsung’s third-quarter results and SK hynix’s record profit showed how strongly AI demand and memory pricing have supported chipmaking earnings.
Why the Case Survived
Wise distinguished the complaint from an earlier DRAM lawsuit whose dismissal was upheld on appeal in 2022. She considered the combined allegations about capacity decisions, customer restrictions and contracts sufficient to let this case proceed.
The allegations also cover long-term commitments of HBM supply, refusals to offer long-term conventional DRAM contracts, Micron’s closure of its Crucial consumer business and similar customer-vetting practices.
The judge did not give weight to every argument the buyers advanced. Industry-conference meetings and public references to supply discipline did not strengthen their case under the applicable precedent.
The manufacturers must answer the complaint by December 7. An initial case management conference is scheduled for January 12, 2027, leaving the central question – whether the supply decisions were coordinated – to be tested as the litigation proceeds.