Markets

Defensive Stocks Lead Nasdaq 100 by 26 Points, Morgan Stanley Says

Consumer staples, health care and utilities gained an average 13% as the Nasdaq 100 fell 13%, creating the widest defensive lead in 25 years, Morgan Stanley says.

By Benjamin Harper Edited by Michael Foster Published: Updated:
Defensive Stocks Lead Nasdaq 100 by 26 Points, Morgan Stanley Says
Defensive sectors have outperformed the Nasdaq 100 by 26 percentage points since October 1, Morgan Stanley says. The bank’s New York headquarters sign appears in a 2011 file photo. Photo: Alex Proimos / Flickr 

Key Notes

  • Morgan Stanley says defensive sectors lead the Nasdaq 100 by 26 percentage points since October 1.
  • Consumer staples, health care and utilities averaged a 13% gain as the Nasdaq 100 fell 13% through November 16.
  • The bank says a comparable six-week defensive lead was last seen in September and October 2001.

Defensive stocks have opened a 26-percentage-point lead over the Nasdaq 100 this quarter, the biggest such rotation in 25 years, according to Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS). The gap has widened as technology shares have weakened.

The S&P 500’s consumer staples, health care and utilities sectors gained an average of 13% from October 1 through November 16, while the Nasdaq 100 fell 13%. The bank’s derivatives team published the figures in a November 16 post.

Three Sectors Pull Ahead

The defensive figure averages three sector indexes, rather than every constituent stock. The 26-point spread is a difference between percentage returns, combining gains on one side with losses on the other.

The Nasdaq 100 tracks 100 of the largest nonfinancial companies listed on Nasdaq, across technology and other industries. Its composition therefore differs from the S&P-based defensive group.

A Gap Last Seen in 2001

The accompanying chart tracks rolling six-week relative returns back to 2000. Morgan Stanley identified September and October 2001 as the last time defensives held a comparable lead over roughly six weeks.

Caution Within the Stock Market

The pattern was already visible in late October, when 25 prominent stocks touched new highs during a broad selloff. Health care and consumer businesses supplied many of those records even as AI-linked shares weakened.

For Morgan Stanley, the split signals investor caution expressed through sector selection: weakness in one part of the equity market has coincided with strength elsewhere.

Disclaimer: MarketSpeaker content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Verify information independently and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.

Markets, News, Stocks